The show “Pretty Little Liars” has dug itself into a hole with a tweet many are calling transphobic.
On August 24, the ABC Family show’s official Twitter account sent out a post to its more than 3 million followers with a wildly problematic caption referring to Charlotte DiLaurentis, a transgender character on the show. “He. She. It. Charlotte. #PrettyLittleLiars,” the caption read.
Though the tweet has since been deleted, Parker Molloy, a writer for Upworthy, took a screenshot before it was taken down and posted it on Twitter.
“He. She. It. Charlotte.”
You guys.
Why? pic.twitter.com/tk3X60sz8c
— Parker Molloy (@ParkerMolloy) August 24, 2015
The character Charlotte DiLaurentis, born Charles DiLaurentis, is a trans woman on “Pretty Little Liars” and was revealed to be the show’s villain known as “A.” Though the original post no longer exists, it continues to receive negative attention and criticisms for the pronouns it used to identify the transgender character. Twitter users quickly reached out to ABC Family (@ABCFamily) and the show’s official account (@ABCFpll) to condemn the language used in the tweet and accompanying graphic.
.@ABCFamily & .@ABCFpll you have the responsibility of teaching your viewers that misgendering a trans person or calling them “it” is not ok
— The Other Nic (@CloneNic) August 24, 2015
.@ABCFpll This is transphobic and v damaging to your trans teen fans. Please do better.
— Diane Shipley (@dianeshipley) August 24, 2015
@ABCFpll I hate whoever runs this account. I sincerely do. Calling a trans character it? You are an abomination.
— Phaedra (@vrayisgod) August 24, 2015
@ABCFamily @ABCFpll way to disrespect trans women. We are not It! We are women not he! And stop making us villains https://t.co/MtjSDRTwyq
— Sophia (@Pragmaticuseles) August 24, 2015
The account has since reposted the original graphic with tweet text reading, “She came. She saw. She conquered.” The graphic itself, however, still features a quote in which the character is described with “he” pronouns. Twitter users pointed out the repeated misuse of pronouns and implored the account to pay more attention to the way it discusses transgender characters.
@ABCFamily please get someone on staff who actually has a basic understanding of how to talk about trans people
— Catherine (@CMeushaw) August 24, 2015
@ABCFamily No, just NO!!! You guys still don’t get it.
Take the graphic down, and NEVER use it again!
— Ildi K. (@saii79) August 24, 2015
. @ABCFamily -by continually posting stuff like this, you’re *still* pushing for the character to be misgendered. That’s irresponsible.
— JAPSPEPORJ FENWAY (@SidizenKane) August 24, 2015
After reaching out for comment on the deleted tweet via email, The Huffington Post received this response from ABC Family spokesperson Jori Arancio:
This tweet was in reference to lines Spencer and Hanna have said in previous episodes venting their frustration about not knowing the identity or gender of their tormentor (“A”). It was spoken by these characters a season before they found out that “A” was a transgender character. We updated the reference by including the name Charlotte because it was revealed that Charlotte is “A.” Once it was tweeted we realized that it could be misinterpreted, and in no way wanted to offend anyone, so we immediately deleted the tweet.
In light of the tweets, showrunner I. Marlene King shared a post on Instagram. She explained the show’s cast, crew and creators are not involved with the show’s accounts and also shared her support for the LGBT community.
“I encourage all people to be their true selves. And offer my support to the LGBT community,” she wrote in the caption.
I encourage all people to be their true selves. And offer my support to the LBGT community.
A photo posted by @imarleneking on Aug 25, 2015 at 7:32am PDT
“Pretty Little Liars” received backlash before when the villain known as “A” was revealed to be a trans woman. In a blog for The Huffington Post, Brynn Tannehill, director of advocacy for LGBT military community SPARTA, explained the show reinforced “negative stereotypes” of transgender people.
“They managed to create a character that simultaneously exemplifies all the negative stereotypes that prevent transgender people from getting jobs, receiving health care, finding housing and being accepted as who they are by their families,” she wrote.
With these recent tweets, it looks like the show has a long way to go when it comes to its representation of transgender people.
H/T Cambio
Also on HuffPost:
– This feed and its contents are the property of The Huffington Post, and use is subject to our terms. It may be used for personal consumption, but may not be distributed on a website.