The combination of icy eye shadow and a minidress might sound like a ’90s fashion disaster, but Jennifer Lopez managed to make the combination look decidedly chic.

Lopez donned blue eye shadow and a collared Marchesa Notte Resort 2015 dress adorned with flowers for the “American Idol XIV” Top Finalists Party at the District restaurant in Los Angeles Wednesday. The 45-year-old looked gorgeous as she posed for photos on the carpet with fellow judges Keith Urban and Harry Connick Jr.

Although Lopez looked topnotch, Ryan Seacrest joked about “Idol’s” low ratings during the show earlier in the night, referencing “Empire” and saying: “To be number one … Oh yes, I remember those days.”