New York Fashion Week had it all this season from outfits made out of sheer pantyhose to creepily gothic snowsuits. Some of the week’s least wearable looks were so outrageous that even the most fashion-obsessed might have trouble taking them seriously.

To prove that point, Jimmy Kimmel decided to test his studio audience on a few real and fake fashion week looks and as you might suspect, the results were just as hilarious as last year.